Are you thinking of sailing away this summer but harbouring doubts as to which cruise line is right for you? There’s a whole yacht of things to consider before you anchor your decision!
Whether you’re planning a fun-filled family trip, a romantic escape into the sunset, or a party holiday with friends, choosing the right cruise line is essential to make sure everyone has an unforgettable time.
Two names that are sure to come up are the famed Carnival Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean International. These cruise industry giants boast fantastic itineraries, onboard activities, dining options, and accommodations. But which one is the right fit for you?
This Carnival Cruise vs. Royal Caribbean guide from the Slingo Lifestyle Blog compares the two cruise lines across key categories. By the end, you’ll understand what each cruise line offers and which one is better suited to your travel preferences.
Already got a priority in mind? Jump to a section below for our deep dive:
- Carnival Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean International: A Brief Overview
- Itineraries and Destinations
- Rooms and Cabins
- Dining and Bars
- Activities and Entertainment
- Cruise Costs
- The Final Scores: Is Carnival Better than Royal Caribbean?
Carnival Cruise Line vs Royal Caribbean International: A Brief Overview
Carnival Cruise Line
Founded in 1972, Carnival Cruise Line has become a household name because of its vibrant party atmosphere. Carnival is a top choice for travellers looking for a premium cruising experience with a laid-back vibe.
The line caters to a wide range of guests, from families to young adults, with a focus on fun, affordability, and fantastic onboard activities.
Carnival's fleet includes the following classes of ships:
- Mardi Gras Class: The newest ships in the fleet, featuring the first roller coaster at sea and a variety of themed zones.
- Vista Class: Known for their expansive outdoor spaces, these ships offer stunning ocean views and a mix of relaxation and adventure.
- Dream Class: Large ships packed with entertainment options, from water parks to unique dining experiences.
- Spirit Class: Smaller, more intimate ships that can access more ports, making for a more traditional cruise experience.
- Fantasy Class: The older, smaller ships in the fleet are known for their classic Carnival charm and affordability.
Carnival sails to popular destinations like the Caribbean, Mexico, Alaska, and even the Mediterranean, providing a wide range of itineraries for all travellers.
Royal Caribbean
Established in 1968, Royal Caribbean International is a giant in the cruise industry, boasting equally giant ships. The line has something for everyone, including families, couples, and adventure seekers, with boats, itineraries, and activities to delight everyone on board.
Royal Caribbean's fleet includes the following classes of ships:
- Icon Class: The newest and largest in its fleet, complete with incredible amenities like the largest at-sea waterpark and an ice rink.
- Oasis Class: Huge ships featuring neighbourhoods, a park with real trees, and the famous AquaTheater.
- Quantum Class: High-tech ships with unique features like a 300ft observation capsule and a skydiving simulator.
- Freedom Class: Feature a mix of activities, dining options, and relaxation spaces, ideal for couples and groups of friends.
- Voyager Class: Introduced rock-climbing walls and ice-skating rinks at sea, setting a new standard for onboard entertainment.
- Radiance Class: Classy, mid-size ships designed with more glass, offering unbeatable ocean views and a more intimate cruising experience.
Royal Caribbean’s itineraries span the globe, with ships sailing to the Caribbean (who would have guessed!), Europe, Asia, and beyond.
Carnival Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean: Which is Best?
Now you know a little more about these cruise lines, it’s time to get into our comparison. Here, we’ll explore the companies’ itineraries and destinations, accommodations, food and drink options, on-board activities and costs, to see which is best.
Itineraries and Destinations
When choosing a cruise, the destinations you visit are just as important as the ship itself. So, let's dive into the destinations that Carnival and Royal Caribbean travel to and see which aligns with your travel goals.
Carnival Cruises
Carnival’s cruises are generally shorter and more affordable. Yet, their selection of itineraries provides plenty of opportunities to explore beautiful destinations, particularly in the Americas.
Carnival's itineraries include:
- Caribbean: With options covering the Eastern, Western, and Southern Caribbean, these trips often feature stops at popular ports like Cozumel, Grand Cayman, and the Bahamas.
- Bahamas: Carnival operates numerous short cruises to the Bahamas, making it easy to escape to paradise for a few days.
- Mexico: The Mexican Riviera cruises take you along the Pacific coast, visiting ports such as Cabo San Lucas, Puerto Vallarta, and Mazatlán.
- Alaska: Carnival’s seasonal Alaska cruises feature beautiful itineraries that showcase the state's stunning glaciers and wildlife.
- Hawaii: Although less frequent, Carnival does organise Hawaiian cruises, giving you the chance to explore these tropical islands.
- Transatlantic and Panama Canal: For those seeking a more unique adventure, Carnival hosts transatlantic crossings and Panama Canal itineraries on select ships.
Ranging from 3-8 nights, Carnival’s itineraries are typically shorter, making them perfect for first-time cruisers or those looking for a quick getaway. Their schedules provide a balance of time to enjoy onboard activities and exciting shore excursions without venturing too far from the Americas.
Royal Caribbean
On the other hand, Royal Caribbean is known for its extensive global reach. With longer and more varied itineraries, the cruise line caters to seasoned travellers seeking to explore multiple continents.
Royal Caribbean's itineraries include:
- Caribbean and Bahamas: Like Carnival, Royal Caribbean offers options in the Caribbean and Bahamas, including exclusive stops to ports like Perfect Day at CocoCay (Royal Caribbean’s own private destination).
- Europe: European itineraries span the Mediterranean, Northern Europe, and the Baltic Sea, visiting iconic cities like Rome, Barcelona, and St. Petersburg.
- Alaska: Royal Caribbean’s Alaska cruises are ideal for glacier viewing and wildlife spotting, often paired with land tours for a once-in-a-lifetime exploring experience.
- Asia: The cruise line’s Asian itineraries sail to regions like Southeast Asia, China, and Japan to provide unique cultural experiences and scenic landscapes.
- Australia and New Zealand: Seasonal cruises in Australia and New Zealand provide a chance to explore these countries' stunning coastlines and vibrant cities.
- World Cruises and Transpacific: Royal Caribbean arranges world cruises and transpacific itineraries for the ultimate journey, giving guests the chance to explore multiple continents on a single voyage.
Royal Caribbean’s itineraries are typically longer, ranging from 7 to 14 nights, extending to as long as 100-day world cruises. These trips are ideal for travellers seeking to immerse themselves in diverse cultures and far-reaching destinations.
Carnival score: 7.5/10
Royal Caribbean score: 9/10
While Carnival excels in providing affordable, fun-filled cruises to destinations across the Americas, Royal Caribbean boasts a more diverse range of itineraries for global adventures.
If you’re looking for an immersive cultural experience, a Royal Caribbean cruise is for you, but if a short and sweet trip to the Americas will quench your wanderlust, choose a Carnival cruise.
Rooms and Cabins
Visiting breathtaking destinations and trying out new activities isn’t half as enjoyable if you haven’t had your beauty sleep! Comfortable accommodation is just as important as the fun stuff, so let’s explore their accommodations.
Carnival Cruises
Whether you're looking for a basic interior room or a luxurious suite, Carnival has something to suit every budget.
- Interior Cabins: Carnival’s interior cabins are functional and comfortable, offering a cosy retreat after a day of fun. Some ships feature Cove Balconies and private outdoor spaces near the waterline for a unique ocean view.
- Ocean View Cabins: These cabins feature large windows or portholes, allowing guests to enjoy the sea views without stepping up to a balcony room.
- Balcony Cabins: Carnival’s balcony cabins have private outdoor spaces, perfect for enjoying a morning coffee or sunset at sea.
- Suites: For those seeking a luxurious upgrade, Carnival’s suites have separate living areas, larger balconies, and upgraded amenities. The Cloud 9 Spa Suites even include exclusive access to the ship’s spa facilities.
Carnival’s accommodations are known for being spacious and family-friendly, with many connecting rooms and options for larger groups.
While not as luxurious as some competitors, Carnival provides comfort and convenience at a good value for money.
Royal Caribbean
Royal Caribbean’s accommodations cater to a wide range of preferences, from budget-conscious travellers to those seeking the ultimate in luxury.
- Interior Cabins: Royal Caribbean’s interior cabins are basic but modern and comfortable. The Virtual Balcony feature on some ships streams real-time ocean views on a floor-to-ceiling screen.
- Ocean View Cabins: These cabins provide large windows or portholes for natural light and scenic views.
- Balcony Cabins: Royal Caribbean’s balcony cabins are spacious and elegantly designed, with private space to enjoy the ocean breeze.
- Suites: Royal Caribbean has several suites to suit various needs. Royal Suite Class boasts exclusive amenities, concierge services, and access to private lounges and sun decks. Meanwhile, the Ultimate Family Suite, available on select ships, includes features like a slide and an in-room cinema.
Royal Caribbean’s accommodations are among the most well-equipped in the industry, with options to suit every type of traveller and suites that offer a hard-to-beat level of luxury.
Carnival score: 7.5/10
Royal Caribbean score: 9.5/10
Carnival Cruises has several comfortable accommodation options at affordable prices, yet Royal Caribbean stands out with its unique suites and clever features.
If you value a space to unwind and recharge, opt for Royal Caribbean, but if you’re planning to spend most of your cruising time out and about, Carnival’s rooms will suit you just fine.
Love a splendid slumber? Check out our hotel guides for the best in on-land stays:
- Four Seasons or Ritz-Carlton: Battle of Luxury Hotel Giants
- The Ritz vs The Savoy: Which London Luxury Hotel is Best?
- Hilton vs IHG: Which Hotel Chain is Best?
Dining and Bars
Dining is a key part of any cruise experience, especially for the foodies in your group. Get a taste for the culinary delights Carnival and Royal Caribbean serve below.
Carnival Cruises
Carnival is known for its casual, fun dining atmosphere. Its wide range of options caters to all tastes and preferences, including those of gourmet guests.
- Main Dining Rooms: Carnival’s main dining rooms offer a variety of dishes, from comfort food to international cuisine, with flexible dining times to suit your schedule.
- Speciality Restaurants: Carnival’s speciality dining rooms include Italian, steakhouse, and sushi options. For a fine dining experience, try Chef’s Table, where you can enjoy a multi-course meal prepared by the ship’s executive chef.
- Casual Dining: Carnival excels in casual dining, with options like Guy’s Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina, and 24-hour pizzerias.
- Bars and Lounges: Carnival’s bars are unique and varied; its vessels feature island-vibe, traditional, and high-class lounges.
Royal Caribbean
Royal Caribbean has several casual and upmarket restaurants to choose from, as well as unique bar experiences.
- Main Dining Rooms: Royal Caribbean’s main dining rooms feature international dishes, as well as traditional course menus and buffet-style dining.
- Speciality Restaurants: Royal Caribbean’s speciality dining includes options like: Chops Grille (steakhouse), Jamie’s Italian (by Jamie Oliver), and Wonderland (imaginative cuisine). Royal Caribbean also features a Chef’s Table, where guests can enjoy a multi-course gourmet meal.
- Casual Dining: Royal Caribbean boasts a myriad of casual dining options, including the popular Windjammer Café, Sorrento’s Pizza, and Johnny Rockets.
- Bars and Lounges: Royal Caribbean’s bars are some of the most unique at sea. Guests can enjoy piano bars, sky bars, and pool bars. A highlight is the cruise line’s innovative Bionic Bar, where drinks are served by robotic bartenders!
Carnival score: 8/10
Royal Caribbean score: 9/10
Both cruise lines have bountiful dining and drinking choices. Carnival’s late-night bites and casual bars are perfect for the laid-back diner and party animals on board.
Meanwhile, Royal Caribbean’s futuristic bars and chef-operated restaurants give it an upmarket edge and a slight advantage in our rankings.
If awesome dining experiences are at the top of your travel checklist, check out our scenic eateries guide for top eats with stunning settings.
Activities and Entertainment
Cruising is about striking a balance between fabulous destinations and fun-filled onboard experiences. With activities and destinations for all the family, there’s never a dull moment aboard Carnival or Royal Caribbean. Let’s explore what each has in store.
Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival’s cruises certainly live up to their name! From sunrise to sunset, this line has endless entertainment options, including:
- Daytime Activities: Carnival’s ships feature water parks, mini-golf, ropes courses, and trivia games, ensuring there’s always something to do during the day.
- Evening Entertainment: Evening entertainment includes stand-up comedy clubs, Broadway-style shows, live TV-style quiz shows, live music and a nightclub.
- Unique Features: Carnival boasts BOLT - the first rollercoaster at sea - while the IMAX Theatre on select ships offers an ocean-side cinematic experience.
- Family-Friendly: Carnival is known for its family-friendly atmosphere, with kids' clubs, arcades, and the popular Seuss at Sea program, featuring Dr. Seuss-themed activities and parades.
Carnival’s entertainment is all about fun and excitement, making it an excellent choice for families.
Royal Caribbean
Royal Caribbean vessels feature many ‘first-at-sea’ features and activities, with several entertainment options to seal the deal.
- Daytime Activities: Royal Caribbean’s ships are packed with unique activities, including rock climbing walls, surf simulators, ice skating rinks, and zip lines.
- Evening Entertainment: Royal Caribbean’s evening entertainment includes full-scale Broadway shows, ice skating spectaculars, and high-diving performances in the AquaTheater.
- Unique Features: Royal Caribbean’s ships feature innovative attractions, including an observation capsule, a skydiving simulator, and the Ultimate Abyss 10-story slide.
- Family-Friendly: Royal Caribbean offers activities for younger travellers, including kids' clubs and teen lounges, whilst many of its unique features provide fun for all the family.
Royal Caribbean’s entertainment options are some of the most innovative and varied at sea, catering to guests of all ages and interests.
Carnival score: 8/10
Royal Caribbean score: 9.5/10
Carnival has everything you need for fun-filled days and evenings at sea, with both adventurous and relaxing things to do, but Royal Caribbean’s adrenaline-pumping activities and family-friendly features give it the wow factor.
Cruise Costs
Cost is always a key consideration when booking a cruise, so let's see how Carnival and Royal Caribbean compare in terms of pricing.
Carnival Cruise Line
Carnival is known for its affordability, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious travellers.
- Base Prices: Carnival’s cruises are typically less expensive than other major cruise lines, with interior cabins for a 7-night Caribbean cruise starting around £500 per person.
- Value for Money: Carnival offers good value, with plenty of amenities and activities included. They also frequently run promotions that include onboard credit, beverage packages, and discounted fares.
- Additional Costs: While Carnival’s base prices are lower, some specialty dining, shore excursions, and onboard activities do incur additional costs.
Royal Caribbean
Royal Caribbean’s cruises are generally priced higher than Carnival’s, reflecting the more luxurious and innovative experiences they provide.
- Base Prices: For a comparable 7-night Caribbean cruise, interior cabins on Royal Caribbean start around £600 per person, with balcony rooms for roughly £900 per person.
- Value for Money: While Royal Caribbean’s prices are higher, the range of activities, dining options, and entertainment included in the fare often justifies the cost. They also run promotions that include extras like drink packages and onboard credit.
- Additional Costs: As with Carnival, some speciality dining, shore excursions, and unique onboard experiences on Royal Caribbean may come with additional fees.
Carnival score: 9/10
Royal Caribbean score: 8.5/10
While Royal Caribbean offers a more luxurious experience, Carnival’s affordability and value for money make it a strong contender for budget-conscious travellers.
Prices will vary based on the destination, room and time of year you want to book.
Carnival Cruises vs Royal Caribbean: The Verdict?
So is Royal Caribbean or Carnival better? Now that we’ve compared the two cruise lines across our five key categories let’s tally up the scores:
Carnival final score: 40/50
Royal Caribbean final score: 45.5/50
In our comparison, Royal Caribbean takes the crown with 9’s across the board, but Carnival isn’t far behind on the podium! Ultimately, the best cruise line for you depends on your personal preferences, budget, and travel style, so here are a few key takeaways to bear in mind when deciding between them:
Choose Carnival if you're looking for:
- An affordable and fun-filled cruise
- Shorter itineraries in the Americas
- A family-friendly atmosphere with plenty of activities
- Good value for money
- A range of casual and classier dining options
Opt for Royal Caribbean if you're after:
- A more luxurious and innovative cruise
- Longer, global itineraries with cultural experiences
- Cutting-edge activities and high-production value entertainment
- Unique bars and restaurants
Set Sail with Slingo
Ready to embark on a Royal Caribbean Cruise? Explore these guides to learn more about the ships in their fleet:
- Symphony of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas: Which Cruise Best?
- Oasis of the Seas vs Symphony of the Seas: Which is Best?
Or, broaden your horizons and check out these guides comparing other cruise lines:
- Princess Cruises vs Royal Caribbean: Which Is Right For You?
- Which Is Best: Celebrity Cruises vs Princess Cruises?
- Which is Best: Norwegian Cruise Line or Royal Caribbean?
DISCOVER SLINGO
YOUR OFFICIAL SITE FOR SLINGO GAMES
Slingo is a vibrant online casino with a fantastic selection of Slingo games, online slots, live tables and more.
Join The Fun on Slingo.Com!
